Everyone has an opinion.
I’ll never forget the unexpected stress I experienced around my food choices after being diagnosed with cancer. One well-meaning friend handed me a list of foods to avoid. Another suggested I eliminate meat. Someone else thought I should follow a strict plant-based diet, while others insisted that certain supplements were the answer.
Everyone seemed to have an opinion, and everyone was convinced they were right.
Maybe you’ve been there too.
Today, with social media added to the mix, I think it’s even harder to figure out what we should and shouldn’t eat. Keto, carnivore, paleo, vegetarian, vegan, intermittent fasting, raw food, detox cleanses, and the list goes on and on. Influencers, companies, and even some health professionals promote their favorite eating plans, sometimes leaving out important details about the research that might cause you to think twice.
When you’re trying to improve your health, the last thing you need is another set of food rules that leaves you confused, overwhelmed, or spending money on something that may not provide the benefits promised. Over the last twenty years, I’ve become less interested in random advice from people who don’t know me and more interested in what research says about how food affects our bodies - and how we can support our health.
So let’s take a closer look at some of today’s most popular diets and what the research actually says about them. Some have strong scientific support, others have benefits worth considering, and a few raise some serious nutritional concerns.
Mediterranean diet: A flexible place to start
The Mediterranean diet has been around long before it became a popular health trend. Based on traditional eatingpatterns in countries bordering the Mediterranean Sea, it emphasizes vegetables, fruits, beans, lentils, whole grains, nuts,seeds, fish, and olive oil. And unlike many of the diets we’ll talk about, this one has decades of solid research behind it, particularly when it comes to heart health and reducing the risk of certain chronic diseases. Let me share two studies that stand out to me.
What the Research Shows
The first is PREDIMED, a large clinical trial in Spain involving 7,447 adults between the ages of 55 and 80 who were at high risk for heart disease. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three groups: a Mediterranean diet with extra-virgin olive oil, a Mediterranean diet with mixed nuts, or a control group that was simply advised to cut back on fat.
After about five years, both Mediterranean groups had roughly 30 percent fewer heart attacks, strokes, and deaths from cardiovascular disease than the control group. The second study followed nearly 26,000 healthy American women for up to two years in the Women's Health Study. Women who ate the most Mediterranean-style diet had about a 25 percent lower risk of cardiovascular events, such as heart attack and stroke, than those who ate the least.
So why does it work? It likely isn't any single food. Extra-virgin olive oil contains polyphenols, antioxidant plant compounds that help calm inflammation and protect cells from damage. Beans, nuts, and whole grains provide fiber that gut bacteria break down into short-chain fatty acids. These compounds help regulate inflammation. It's the combination of these foods, eaten consistently over time, that seems to make the difference.
Is it perfect? Not necessarily. Some people find it expensive to purchase fresh fish, nuts, and high-quality olive oil. Others focus too heavily on pasta, cheese, and wine while overlooking the plant foods that make this eating pattern so beneficial. A big plate of fettuccine Alfredo and a second glass of wine isn't exactly what the researchers had in mind.
If cost is a concern, you don't need to shop at a specialty store. Canned beans and lentils, frozen vegetables, oats, brown rice, and canned salmon or sardines all fit beautifully into this way of eating and won't break the budget. One caveat: if you buy canned foods be sure they are BPA-free.
Still the overall approach makes a lot of sense, and the research backs it up.
My take: A diet built around whole foods, healthy fats, and plenty of plants is a good foundation for long-term health. This is how I eat. It is partially responsible for why I recovered and remain cancer free 21 years later.
Keto: what happens when you eliminate most carbohydrates?
The ketogenic diet has attracted quite a following, particularly among people looking to lose weight or improve blood sugar levels. The idea is relatively simple. You drastically reduce carbohydrates, increase fat consumption, and encourage your body to use fat rather than glucose as its primary fuel source. This metabolic state is called ketosis. Ketogenic diets have medical uses, particularly for some forms of epilepsy. When used for this purpose, they require medical supervision.
The keto diet is not a one-size-fits-all way of eating. When you eliminate most fruits, beans, lentils, and whole grains, you're also eliminating important sources of fiber, vitamins, minerals, and phytonutrients, resulting in significant nutrient deficiencies that can, among other complications, result in muscle wasting. Another concern I have is that some versions of keto encourage people to replace these foods with large quantities of butter, bacon, cheese, and other high-fat animal products. Depending on food choices, this can increase saturated fat consumption and LDL cholesterol. The type of fatand the overall quality of the diet matter.
Because keto limits many fiber-rich plant foods, it can be harder to get enough fiber. The beneficial bacteria in our gut rely on dietary fiber and other compounds from plant foods. When those foods disappear from our diets, we're changing the environment in which our gut microbiome operates and increasing the risk of developing chronic disease.
My take: Keto may be appropriate for some people with medical guidance, but it isn’t a good long-term choice foreveryone. If you have diabetes, kidney disease, cardiovascular disease, or take a medication that affects blood sugar, talkwith your healthcare team before trying it.
Carnivore: eating only animal products
This is probably the diet that raises the most questions for me. The carnivore diet takes carbohydrate restriction to an entirely different level. Followers eat primarily meat, fish, eggs, and sometimes dairy. Fruits, vegetables, beans, grains, nuts and seeds are eliminated altogether. Some proponents claim it reduces inflammation, improves autoimmune conditions and even resolves digestive challenges, but long-term evidence for those claims is lacking.
Some people report they feel better after starting on the diet, and there may be a few reasons for that, including eliminating highly processed foods, increasing protein intake, and simplifying food choices. However, those are short-term results, but they don’t tell us how people may feel after following the diet long term. To be sure, animal foodsprovide important nutrients such as protein, iron, zinc, and vitamin B12. Eliminating plant foods means fiber, critical to your microbiome, is removed along with critical nutrients such as vitamin C, folate, magnesium, potassium, and phytonutrients.
Because the diet excludes plant foods, it provides little to no fiber and may be difficult to balance nutritionally over the long term. A 2026 review examining the carnivore diet found that long-term clinical evidence remains extremely limited and identified several potential nutritional and cardiovascular concerns.
My take: I find this approach particularly concerning. We have decades of research showing the benefits associated with eating beans, vegetables, fruits, nuts, and whole grains. Why would we eliminate these foods without strong evidence that doing so improves our health? I simply don't see a compelling nutritional reason to recommend the carnivore diet as a long-term way of eating.
Paleo: Is it really eating like our ancestors?
The paleo diet is based on the idea that we should eat more like our hunter-gatherer ancestors. It typically includes meat,fish, eggs, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and seeds, while excluding grains, legumes, dairy, and most processed foods. There are some things I appreciate about this approach. It emphasizes whole foods, reduced refined sugars, and discourages heavily processed products, but I have a problem with eliminating beans and whole grains.
Beans are among the most nutritionally valuable foods we can eat. They provide fiber, plant protein, minerals, and other beneficial compounds. Whole grains also offer important nutrients and fiber and are associated with long-term health.What’s more some ancestral diets included wild legumes and grains such as oats, barley and millet. The idea that our ancestors ate a particular way is difficult to establish. Human diets have varied widely depending on geography, climate and food availability. So there is no single ancestral way of eating.
My take: I agree with the emphasis on eating fewer highly processed foods but not eliminating entire categories of nutritious foods. I would rather have people incorporate more beans, lentils, vegetables, and whole grains than removethem without a clear medical reason.
Vegan and Vegetarianism: Is eliminating all animal products necessary?
Plant-based eating has received plenty of attention, and for good reason. Plant foods supply fiber, protein, antioxidants, vitamins, minerals, and disease-fighting phytonutrients. While research has repeatedly associated higher plant-protein consumption with favorable long-term health outcomes, becoming vegan can be quite challenging. As a former vegan, I can attest that it’s tricky to get the critical nutrients needed for a well-nourished body.
A vegan diet excludes animal-derived foods, including meat, fish, eggs, and dairy. A well-planned version can includeabundant vegetables, fruits, beans, lentils, nuts, seeds, and whole grains, but where vegans can get tripped up is using highly processed meat substitutes, packaged snacks, and refined carbohydrates as a significant portion of the diet. Just because something is vegan doesn’t mean it’s healthy. These prepackaged foods can be high in sodium, contain refinedstarches and be less nutritious than whole foods.
Eating vegan will require extra attention to getting vitamin B12, iron, calcium, iodine, zinc, and omega-3 fatty acids. Vitamin B12 is especially important because reliable sources are generally fortified foods or supplements, adding cost and potential complications.
Vegetarian diets usually exclude meat, poultry, and fish but may include eggs and dairy, which provide a B12 boost without adding supplements. Beans, lentils, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, and whole grains can provide fiber and a widerange of nutrients, while eggs and dairy offer additional protein and critical nutrients such as B vitamins, which help your body convert food into energy, form red blood cells, and maintain a healthy nervous system.
My take: I like the emphasis on plants, but don’t believe everyone needs to be vegan or even vegetarian to benefit from eating more. A thoughtfully planned vegan diet can be nutritious, but it takes effort and short cuts won’t necessarily result in better health. A well-planned vegetarian diet can be a flexible way to eat more plant foods. Focus on a variety of whole or minimally processed plant foods, learn to love to cook, and get professional guidance if you have specifichealth needs. Our bodies are unique and some people may find they do best eating animal protein. What matters is the quality and variety of the foods we consume. Adopting a strong plant-based diet is not just good for our individual long-term health, but it’s a great way to take care of our planet.
Intermittent fasting: Does timing matter?
Unlike the other diets we've discussed, intermittent fasting focuses on when you eat rather than necessarily what you eat. The 16:8 method, for example, involves eating during an eight-hour window and fasting for the remaining sixteen hours of your day. Other approaches involve fasting for longer periods or substantially reducing calories on certain days. Some studies suggest intermittent fasting can help with weight loss, improve insulin sensitivity, and improve certain metabolic markers. For some people, it also simplifies their eating routine by eliminating calorie counting. Studies comparing intermittent fasting with traditional calorie-restricted diets have generally found similar weight-loss results. In other words, the benefit may have more to do with eating less than when you eat.
There are potential downsides, however. Some struggle with hunger, fatigue, headaches, or trouble concentrating.Intermittent fasting may be a poor fit for women who are pregnant or breastfeeding, some people managing diabetes, or those with a history of eating disorders.
My take: I don't think we need to turn eating into another complicated schedule. If intermittent fasting works for you and doesn't interfere with your nutritional needs, then go ahead with it. But I wouldn't choose it simply because someone on social media claims it will reset your metabolism or activate extraordinary healing processes. Listen to your body and be skeptical of hype.
Raw food: Is cooking your food bad?
I've explored this subject in more detail in my earlier article, Food As Medicine: Is the Raw Food Diet Worth It?
A raw food diet emphasizes uncooked or minimally processed foods such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and sproutedgrains. The belief behind this approach is that cooking destroys enzymes and valuable nutrients. While it is true that heat can affect the nutrients in food, the story isn’t that simple.
A strict raw food diet can make it harder to get enough protein, B12, calcium, and iron. Some vitamins, particularly vitamin C and certain B vitamins, are sensitive to heat and can be reduced during cooking. On the other hand, cooking can make other nutrients more available for the body to use. Tomatoes are a good example. Cooking increases the availability of lycopene, an antioxidant associated with several health benefits. Cooking carrots also improves the availability of carotenoids.
There’s one common mistake when eating raw foods: leaving out fat. Some nutrients in vegetables, including vitamins A, E, and K and carotenoids, are better absorbed when eaten with fat. A drizzle of olive oil, a few slices of avocado, or ahandful of nuts can help your body absorb them. Fat-soluble means just what it sounds like. These nutrients dissolve in fat, not water. When fat arrives in your small intestine, your body sends bile to meet it, and the bile bundles the fat and those fat-soluble nutrients into tiny packages your intestinal wall can absorb. No fat, much of the good stuff simply passes on through. You don't need much. A drizzle of good olive oil, a handful of walnuts or pumpkin seeds, a few slices of avocado, a spoonful of tahini or a chopped hard-boiled egg is plenty to unlock what's in that bowl.
My take: I enjoy both raw and cooked foods with a focus on unlocking the highest nutritional value.
Detox diets and juice cleanses: What are we detoxing?
Detox cleanses are everywhere, promising to flush out toxins, reduce inflammation, improve digestion, and give yourbody a fresh start. Some ask you to drink only juice for days; others rely on herbal teas, supplements, or severe calorierestriction. The promises can sound appealing—but your body already has its own detox system.
Your liver, kidneys, lungs, and digestive system work continuously to process and remove waste. There’s little credibleevidence that commercial detox diets or juice cleanses make this natural process work better. That doesn’t mean juicehas no place in your diet. It can provide concentrated nutrients from fruits and vegetables, but juicing removes much ofthe fiber you’d get by eating them whole. And if you rely on juice alone, you’ll likely miss out on protein, healthy fats,and other important nutrients.
Detox products can pose risks, too. Some supplements and herbal ingredients may interact with medications or causeother health problems. Be particularly careful with restrictive cleanses if you have liver or kidney disease or takemedication.
My take: I’d much rather see people support their body's natural processes by eating a wide variety of colorful whole foods and drinking plenty of water. We don't need an expensive cleanse to do that.
Gluten-free: Is it healthier for everyone?
Gluten-free eating has become another popular wellness trend. For people with celiac disease, avoiding gluten is medically necessary. Individuals with wheat allergies or certain forms of gluten sensitivity may also need to avoid specific foods. But what about everyone else?
There is no established health advantage to eliminating gluten if you tolerate it. In fact, many commercially available gluten-free products contain less fiber and fewer nutrients than their whole-grain counterparts. Some are also higher in added sugar, salt, and fat.
Naturally gluten-free foods such as beans, vegetables, fruits, buckwheat, corn, quinoa, oats and rice can certainly be part of a healthy diet. But replacing whole grains with highly processed gluten-free products doesn't necessarily improve your health.
My take: If you have a medical reason to avoid gluten, follow your medical team’s advice. Otherwise, I wouldn't eliminate nutritious whole grains simply because gluten-free has become a popular label.
Heal Just For Today
After looking at these different eating plans, I think we forget about an important part of the conversation. We spend alot of time talking about what to eliminate that we often dismiss what our bodies need to thrive. When I look at the research, one thing continues to stand out. Eating patterns that include a wide variety of colorful, whole plant foods are consistently associated with better long-term health outcomes.
Beans, lentils, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, and whole grains provide much more than calories and protein. They supply fiber, resistant starch, vitamins, minerals, and thousands of phytonutrients that interact with our gut microbiome and support the many processes that keep our bodies functioning. For me, plants are the foundation, and I don't eat meat every day. I also pay close attention to the quality of the animal products I purchase. You’ll find more on that in my blog Animal Protein: Looking Beyond the Label.
Along the way, I’ve learned that being perfect with my food isn’t necessarily helpful. In fact, worrying constantly about what I should or shouldn’t eat can become another source of stress. Science doesn't give us a list of perfect foods or a single eating plan that works for everyone. It gives us information we can use to make better choices.
The goal isn’t to follow a perfect diet. It’s to make informed choices and find an approach that works for you. Maybetoday you add a handful of beans to a meal that normally wouldn’t include them. Perhaps you replace a processed snack with some fresh berries and walnuts. Or you make vegetables the largest part of your plate. These aren’t dramatic changes, but they can add up.
Don’t blindly follow the latest trend. Cutting out a whole food group won’t necessarily make you healthier, and it’s worth being cautious of promised dramatic results. Your body needs a variety of nutrients to maintain healthy cells, support the immune system, repair tissues, and carry out the countless biological processes that keep you healthy. Give it the ingredients it needs.